A Controversial Concept Sparks Questions
A recent media pitch has stimulated public debate and widespread confusion: a reality TV show titled The American, where immigrants would compete in challenges for a chance at U.S. citizenship. The show’s premise quickly drew headlines and concern—but does it hold any legal weight?
What Was Proposed?
The idea for The American was brought forward by Canadian-born producer Rob Worsoff, known for his work on Duck Dynasty. The show would reportedly involve contestants participating in state-themed challenges—like making pizza in New York—with the winner being granted U.S. citizenship in a televised ceremony.
Worsoff claimed that the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) was considering the project. However, no documentation or official agreement has surfaced to support this claim.
DHS Responds: No Approval or Involvement
In response to widespread media coverage, the Department of Homeland Security firmly denied any involvement with the proposed reality show. Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin issued a statement on May 16, 2025, clarifying that the claim Secretary Kristi Noem backed the project was “completely false” and emphasized:
| “Secretary Noem has not ‘backed’ nor is even aware of the pitch of any scripted or reality show… This pitch has not received approval or rejection by staff.” — DHS Assistant Secretary Tricia McLaughlin (source) |
The DHS also emphasized that Secretary Kristi Noem was not involved or aware of the project. The statement labeled the media coverage of the alleged collaboration as “inaccurate and misleading,” further confirming that U.S. immigration policy is not influenced or modeled via entertainment proposals.
What the Law Actually Says About Citizenship
Citizenship in the United States is not something that can be granted through contests or media programs. It is governed by the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA), which outlines a clear and structured legal path to naturalization. The process is managed by USCIS and involves:
- Lawful permanent residency (green card status)
- Continuous residence and physical presence in the U.S.
- Demonstrating good moral character
- Passing English and civics tests
- Taking the Oath of Allegiance
For more details, USCIS provides a helpful breakdown of the 10 Steps to Naturalization.
Public Reaction and Concerns
The idea has been met with heavy criticism from advocacy groups, the media, and late-night television. Comparisons to The Hunger Games and concerns about “gamifying” immigration have surfaced, with many viewing the concept as trivializing the serious nature of becoming a U.S. citizen.
Though Worsoff described the show as a “celebration of immigration” and clarified that losing contestants would not face deportation, critics argue that the show’s concept misrepresents the legal and emotional weight of the immigration journey.
Why It Matters
Even if this proposal never moves forward, it raises an important issue: the spread of misinformation about immigration pathways. Media portrayals like this could give false hope to individuals who are navigating an already complex and often stressful process.
It’s a reminder of why it’s crucial to stay informed through trusted sources, such as official government websites (like USCIS.gov) or qualified immigration attorneys.
The Bottom Line
There is currently no reality show that can grant U.S. citizenship. The American remains an unapproved proposal with no legal authority. The path to citizenship remains strictly governed by established U.S. laws and processes.
If you have any questions about navigating the U.S. immigration process, contact our office today to set up a consultation with one of our attorneys!
Ready to have Berardi on your side?
Whether you’re a business looking to hire or a professional hoping to relocate, immigration law can be complicated. But you don’t have to do it alone. Put our experience to work for you.