TLDR: If your company sponsors a foreign worker for an H-1B visa or employment-based green card, you’re required to pay them a “prevailing wage”, the government-set minimum for that role in that location. The Department of Labor (DOL) assigns a wage level (I through IV) based on the worker’s experience, education, and job duties. Getting the wage level wrong can sink a petition, trigger an audit, or expose your company to back-pay liability. This article breaks down how prevailing wage and wage level determinations work, why they matter, and what employers and workers need to know.
If you’ve ever sponsored a foreign worker for an H-1B visa or an employment-based green card, you’ve encountered the term “prevailing wage.” It sounds straightforward enough, pay the worker the going rate for the job. But the details matter a lot, and getting them wrong can jeopardize your entire case. Whether you’re an employer trying to stay compliant or a foreign worker trying to understand what you should be earning, this guide is for you.
What Is a Prevailing Wage Determination?
A prevailing wage determination (PWD) is an official finding by the U.S. Department of Labor of the minimum wage an employer must pay a sponsored foreign worker for a specific job in a specific geographic area. The goal is straightforward: protect U.S. workers from wage depression and ensure foreign workers aren’t underpaid.
Prevailing wages are required for several visa and green card categories, including H-1B, H-1B1, and E-3 specialty occupation visas, and employment-based green cards filed through the PERM labor certification process. If you’re sponsoring someone through either of these pathways, a PWD is not optional, it’s the foundation of the case.
The DOL primarily uses wage data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics (OEWS) survey to calculate prevailing wages. These figures are updated periodically and vary by job title, SOC (Standard Occupational Classification) code, and geographic area.
Understanding the Four Wage Levels
This is where things get granular, and where a lot of cases run into trouble. The DOL doesn’t just assign one wage for each job title. Instead, it assigns one of four wage levels based on the specific duties and requirements of the position. Each level corresponds to a different tier of skill, experience, and supervisory responsibility.
- Wage Level I: Entry Level
Level I is for workers who are new to a role and perform routine tasks under close supervision. They apply basic skills with minimal independent judgment. Think of a recent graduate stepping into their first professional role.
- Wage Level II: Qualified
Level II applies to workers who can perform a range of tasks with some independence, apply a solid base of knowledge to their work, and may occasionally guide less experienced colleagues. This is the most commonly assigned level in many professional fields.
- Wage Level III: Experienced
Level III is for workers with a track record of experience, specialized expertise, and the ability to exercise significant independent judgment. They often have specialized skills that take years to develop and may lead projects or teams.
- Wage Level IV: Fully Competent
Level IV represents the top tier, workers who are fully competent professionals performing complex, high-stakes duties. They typically set direction, manage others, or function as subject matter experts at the highest level within their field.
The level assigned directly determines the minimum wage an employer must pay. A Level I wage can be significantly lower than a Level IV wage for the same job title in the same city, sometimes by tens of thousands of dollars per year.
How Is the Wage Level Determined?
The wage level is not determined by a worker’s resume alone. The DOL evaluates the actual job duties described in the job description and the specific requirements of the position as posted. Here’s what the agency looks at:
- The complexity and variety of tasks required
- The degree of supervision the employee receives
- The level of independent judgment exercised
- Whether the role involves supervising others
- The degree of specialized knowledge required
- Education and experience requirements as stated in the job posting
This is a critical point: the wage level is tied to the job, not just the person. An employer cannot assign a Level I wage to a complex position simply because the worker is willing to accept it. The job duties and requirements must genuinely match the assigned level.
How to Obtain a Prevailing Wage Determination
For PERM labor certification cases (EB-2 and EB-3 green cards), employers must submit a PWD request to the DOL’s National Prevailing Wage Center (NPWC) using Form ETA-9141. The NPWC reviews the submitted job description and issues a formal wage determination that is valid for a set period.
For H-1B petitions, employers have two options:
- Submit a PWD request to the NPWC for an official DOL determination
- Use another legitimate wage source, such as a private wage survey published by a recognized source, if it meets DOL standards
In practice, using the OEWS-based DOL determination is the most straightforward and defensible approach for most employers. Private wage surveys can be used but must meet strict requirements and are subject to scrutiny during audits.
Why Wage Level Determinations Matter So Much
Wage level assignments carry significant legal and financial consequences. Here’s why employers and workers should take them seriously:
- Petition Denials and RFEs
USCIS regularly scrutinizes whether the wage level assigned to an H-1B position is consistent with the duties described in the petition. A position described as complex and requiring independent judgment but assigned a Level I wage is a red flag that can lead to a Request for Evidence (RFE) or an outright denial. - DOL Audits and Back Pay
Employers found to have underpaid workers, either by assigning too low a wage level or by failing to pay the certified wage, can be required to pay back wages, face debarment from future immigration filings, and be assessed civil money penalties. These are not hypothetical risks; DOL Wage and Hour Division investigations in this area are ongoing. - Impact on the Worker
For the foreign worker, an incorrect wage level determination can mean being underpaid for years, sometimes without realizing it. Understanding what wage level your position was certified at, and confirming that your actual salary meets or exceeds that threshold, is something every sponsored employee should verify.
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
- Writing job descriptions that don’t match the actual duties of the role
- Assigning Level I wages to positions that genuinely require experience or independent judgment
- Failing to update the prevailing wage when renewing or extending a visa
- Overlooking geographic differentials when an employee works in a different location than the certified worksite
- Assuming a private wage survey will be accepted without proper documentation
Don’t Overlook The Importance of Wage Determinations
Prevailing wage and wage level determinations might not be the most exciting part of immigration law, but they are undeniably one of the most consequential. For employers, getting this right is essential to keeping a petition on solid ground, staying compliant with DOL obligations, and protecting the workers you’ve invested in. For sponsored employees, knowing your wage level and what it means for your paycheck is simply good practice.
If you’re unsure whether your prevailing wage determination is accurate, your wage level assignment makes sense for your position, or your current salary is in compliance, our team of immigration attorneys at Berardi Immigration Law is here to help. A proactive review now can save significant headaches, and expense, down the road.
Questions about prevailing wage compliance or your immigration case? Contact Berardi Immigration Law at 716-643-1010 or click here to book a consultation.
Prevailing Wage Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can an employer pay more than the prevailing wage?
Absolutely, and many do. The prevailing wage is a floor, not a ceiling. Employers can and often do pay above the certified wage. What they cannot do is pay below it.
Q: What happens if the prevailing wage changes after a petition is approved?
Once a prevailing wage is certified and incorporated into an approved petition or labor certification, the employer is generally locked into that wage for the validity of the filing. However, if the position changes, the employee moves to a different worksite, or the employer files a new petition, a fresh PWD will be required reflecting current wage data.
Q: Does the wage level determination apply to all work visa types?
No. Prevailing wage requirements apply specifically to H-1B, H-1B1, E-3, and employment-based green card cases filed through PERM. Other work visa categories such as L-1, TN, or O-1 do not have a formal DOL prevailing wage requirement, though employers are still expected to pay fair market wages and USCIS may consider compensation in assessing a petition’s credibility.
Ready to have Berardi on your side?
Whether you’re a business looking to hire or a professional hoping to relocate, immigration law can be complicated. But you don’t have to do it alone. Put our experience to work for you.